Puget Sound Restoration Fund - Squaxin Island Kelp Bed Restoration

Restoration Project

Puget Sound Restoration Fund - Squaxin Island Kelp Bed Restoration

Restoration Objective:

The bull kelp forest off Squaxin Island in Southern Puget Sound is culturally and ecologically significant. As “People of the Water,” the Squaxin Island Tribe has been sustained by these waters and kelp forests for thousands of years. Over the last 145 years, ~80% of bull kelp forests in southern Puget Sound have disappeared. But the bed off Squaxin Island has persisted, despite being the innermost bed within Puget Sound, and the farthest from the Pacific Ocean. The resilience of the Squaxin Island bed is a powerful symbol for the Tribe, and they watch this kelp bed closely.

In 2013, based on surveys conducted by Washington Department of Natural Resources (DNR), the Squaxin Island kelp bed started noticeably contracting and shoaling. DNR monitors this bed closely as well, in partnership with the Squaxin Island Tribe. Annual surveys conducted over a 10-year period indicate that the kelp bed off Squaxin Island declined 97%, between 2013 and 2022. This was followed by a partial natural recovery in 2023; the 2023 extent was similar to 2016-2021. The most precipitous decline occurred in 2022, following a heat dome event in 2021, during which unusually high daytime tempertures (over 100 °F) coincided with daylight low tides. Only 89 plants reached the surface in 2022.

The near loss of the Squaxin Island kelp bed created an all-hands-on-deck, collective effort to work with the Tribe to re-grow and maintain the kelp forest off Squaxin Island. In fall of 2022, Squaxin Island Tribe worked with DNR to identify the location of a bull kelp enhancement site off Squaxin Island. Simultaneously, the Tribe worked with PSRF to plan bull kelp seed production for an experimental outplanting in winter 2023, with additional outplants planned for 2024, 2025, and 2026.

In July 2024, DNR’s Commissioner of Public Lands announced a formal partnership with the Squaxin Island Tribe to conserve and recover the Squaxin Island kelp bed as the first priority kelp habitat identified via Washington State's Kelp and Eelgrass Health Plan.

Site Selection Criteria:

The site chosen for seed enhancements by the Tribe and DNR is adjacent to, and northwest of the remaining bull kelp bed. The enhancment is also within the footprint of the kelp bed that disappeared most recently, in 2022, following the heat dome event in 2021. The enhancement site also lies within the depth range of the majority of the remaining bed. The other potential enhancement location considered was to the southeast, near Tuxsel Point; it was not preferred because the introduced alga wireweed (Sargassum muticum) is abundant there, along with some naturally occurring bull kelp individuals.

Cause Of Decline:

One major stressor of concern at Squaxin is increasing seawater temperature. To improve understanding, Brooke Weigel, a former post doc at Friday Harbor Labs, conducted a temperature study of the Squaxin Island bed; Helen Berry (DNR) summarized the results as follows: “Brooke Weigel’s paper on the effect of temperature on the early life stages of bull kelp showed gametophyte growth and sporophyte production thermal limits at 16C and 18C. Temperature sensor data from Squaxin Island showed that in 2021 the water temperature exceeded the 16C threshold for a total 618 hours, which preceded the 2022 decrease of kelp. In 2022, the water temperature exceeded the 16C threshold for a total of just 360 hours, which preceded the 2023 partial recovery. Perhaps we saw a partial natural recovery of bull kelp in 2023 in part due to the shorter duration over the 16C temperature threshold in 2022.”

In addition to warm temperature, water quality in Southern Puget Sound is a potential culprit. There are many signals that all is not well with water quality in southern Puget Sound. Bull kelp declines are just one. Dungeness crab fisheries have been closed since 2018, due to population declines. Rockfish populations have also declined. This has exacerbated bull kelp declines, since the decline of top-down predators (such as rock fish and lingcod), has contributed to massive levels of grazing by kelp crabs. Ocean acidification (OA) is also a concern. Excess nutrients from multiple inputs exacerbates OA by fueling algae blooms that settle and decompose, releasing CO2 at depth.

Key Reasons For Decline:

Climate Change

Heatwave

Imbalance

Multiple

Predator loss

Ocean warming

Scientific Paper

Effects of temperature and nutrients on microscopic stages of the bull kelp (Nereocystis luetkeana, Phaeophyceae)

Journal of Phycology.
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/jpy.13366

Site Observations:

Observation Date

21st Mar 2023 – 20th Jun 2024

Action Summary:

PSRF produced bull kelp seed for the Tribe in 2023 and 2024, using kelp material collected in 2021 at the Squaxin Island kelp bed, during an 8-day Kelp Expedition. The Tribe outplanted the seed at the enhancement site on cultivation lines, which were attached to ecology blocks and suspended roughly .5M above the substrate. Outplanting occurred in March of 2023 and February of 2024.

In 2023, two methods were used to produce seed: gametophyte biomass in a sodium alginate binder, and the gravity method (used by Filipe Alberto’s lab at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee). Bull kelp from the alginate treatment grew successfully on the seeded lines, measuring 1,500 linear feet, emerging in June and growing through the summer. The Tribe monitored the enhancement site through early September, using both divers and a remotely-operated vehicle. Kelp crab grazing was significant, posing an ongoing challenge to bull kelp at this location.

In 2024, based on the 2023 enhancement results, kelp seed was produced using the sodium alginate binder only. It was adhered to two different surfaces: 1,500 feet of twine, and beach rocks. The seeded line was wound around the existing cultivation lines, and the “painted” beach rocks were placed at the site within the enhancement area. The Tribe also implemented experimental treatments to assess/address kelp crabs. As of June 20, 2024, no bull kelp was visible on either the seeded lines or beach rocks and kelp crabs were abundant on all surfaces.

The Squaxin Island kelp material used to produce seed for the enhancement is archived as part of a Puget Sound Kelp Seed bank held at two locations: the Alberto Lab, at University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, and PSRF’s Kelp Lab, located at NOAA’s Manchester Research Station. The Seed Bank includes genetic material from 25+ kelp forests around Puget Sound, encompassing the Strait of Juan de Fuca, the San Juan Islands, Admiralty Inlet, Central Sound, and South Sound.

Lessons Learned:

Kelp in 2023 emerged much later than anticipated, which has led us to consider conducting multiple outplants, in succession, to learn more about optimal outplant timing at the site. In 2024, the living paint/alginate transfer treatment didn't yield kelp, which the team suspects was due to low gametophyte density in the treatment. The team is developing and implementing protocols to measure and test differing levels of gametophyte density for the 2025 seed transfer.

Project Outcomes:

The all-in effort at Squaxin is a model of how groups will need to come together in the region to conserve and restore kelp beds. In this spirit, in July 2024, DNR’s Commissioner of Public Lands announced a formal partnership with the Squaxin Island Tribe to conserve and recover the Squaxin Island kelp bed as the first priority kelp habitat identified via the Kelp and Eelgrass Health Plan.

Area of Restoration (Ha)

0.2

Distance to nearest kelp forest (in metres)

10

Indicator Data:

Transplant Info:
Life Stage:Juveniles
Source:Culture